Quantcast

Miss Hayes and her Grade 2's

Classroom stories about my little critters in Grade 2 in South Africa

Sponsored Links

To ask or not to ask...

After school today we had a presentation by an educational company of educational books.  The representative informed us that when teaching a new concept, we should never ask the children if they know anything about the topic before we have taught it.  She explained that this creates the children's thinking that their teachers don't really know what is going on and are asking the kids to inform the teachers.

BUT...

When I was studying, our lecturers always told us that even when it is a new concept or whenever, whatever, however we should always ask the children if they know anything about the topic, what they know about the topic etc. so as to find out where their level is and to create interest in the topic to be thought.

WHICH ONE IS CORRECT?

I am of the opinion that to ask questions constantly arouses creative thinking and generates interest, but now I'm not sure because of this opposing thought that the kids may think I know nothing and that is why I am asking them.

???

Posted: Friday, May 09, 2008 2:41 AM by Jenna

Comments

Betty said:

I disagree with the book representative.  Students love to share prior knowledge, plus it gives the teacher a starting point in her instruction.  I don't think kids view the teacher as not knowing the information if she wants to know what they already know.

# May 9, 2008 10:13 AM

Jenna said:

I totally agree with you.  When the book representative told us that, I looked at her and thought, wow I'm only in my second year of teaching and I know more than you...hehe.  She definitely has the wrong idea.

# May 9, 2008 10:18 AM

Raenette Taljaard said:

I agree with you.  Of course you should start with the known and move towards the unknown.  All teachers know that!  What was the book representative thinking?  She should have got her prior knowledge jacked up before talking to a bunch of teachers!  You must have had some giggles in the staff room!

How are things in Sunny SA?  I can't wait to come on holiday in July to see my family in the Cape!

Raenette

# May 23, 2008 2:22 AM
New Comments to this post are disabled.